Pano with Powerpoint

6 messages Options
Embed this post
Permalink
Flemming V. Larsen

Pano with Powerpoint

Reply Threaded More More options
Print post
Permalink
I know this has been on the list before.
But things might have change since then (new panoplayers etc.) So I like to
know the current options.
I'm looking for the simplest way. iF possible without using apecial software
not found on standard PC/MAC

best regard
Flemming

1drey

Re: Pano with Powerpoint

Reply Threaded More More options
Print post
Permalink
Hi Flemming,

Seems that this question is tabooed here  - I asked it a month ago and didn't get any responce :)

Andrey

--- In [hidden email], "Flemming V. Larsen" <fvl@...> wrote:

>
> I know this has been on the list before.
> But things might have change since then (new panoplayers etc.) So I like to
> know the current options.
> I'm looking for the simplest way. iF possible without using apecial software
> not found on standard PC/MAC
>
> best regard
> Flemming
>


Keith Martin-2

Re: Pano with Powerpoint

Reply Threaded More More options
Print post
Permalink
Sometime around 26/10/09 (at 19:22 +0000) 1drey said:

>Seems that this question is tabooed here - I asked it a month ago
>and didn't get any responce :)

Not taboo to my knowledge - but perhaps nobody has an answer! That's
usually what 'no answer' means... ;-)

PowerPoint isn't great for this. You can insert a QuickTime VR
panorama but it may not work properly across platforms even if
QuickTime is installed. You can't insert a Flash-based .swf panorama.
Basically, PowerPoint is a bad, bad choice. Why this software?

k
Roger Howard-2

Re: Re: Pano with Powerpoint

Reply Threaded More More options
Print post
Permalink
First, it really depends on the platform - PowerPoint presentations  
with embedded media aren't inherently cross-platform. It's common, for  
instance, to see PowerPoints developed on a Mac have lots of empty  
white boxes on Windows; the opposite can be true, too. So if you're  
authoring for PowerPoint, always author on the platform you intend for  
playback *or* stick to only cross-platform features.

It also depends on the version, and (I believe) on the Windows build  
you're running on - for instance, it used to be possible to use the  
Internet Explorer browser ActiveX control in PowerPoint on Windows, so  
you could embed a Web page - which allowed you ugly (but useful) hacks  
like embedding a Quicktime or Flash object in a Web page, and then  
embedding that page in PowerPoint - this no longer works, at least not  
on my work machine (XP SP3, Office 2007, IE8).

Embedding Quicktime content directly in PowerPoint on Windows never  
worked (though there were a few legacy Quicktime video formats which  
worked, but only by accident as Windows Media Player was able to  
decode them - not the case with QTVR content, or really any modern  
video formats).

Embedding Flash in PowerPoint has always been dicey, at best. The best  
I can come up with, right now, is a really ugly hack - embed your SWF  
in a PDF, and then embed the PDF in a PPT. Should work, but probably  
not well. Certainly a lot of trouble - if I went this, route, I'd just  
build my presentation in PDF to begin with (recent Adobe Readers and  
Acrobat have embedded SWF support, though I've never tried this with  
SWF panos it should work).

Also, even if you could get this to work, much as with Keynote and  
QTVR there's an interaction problem kind of inherent to the media -  
PowerPoint tends to want to capture your clicks, so it doesn't lend  
itself well to supporting embedded media that also wants to capture  
clicks (such as for panning a pano).

Sorry couldn't be more help - I'm not (entirely) a PowerPoint hater, I  
live with it, but it's just not geared for this. Ugly hacks may still  
allow it, but they are always that - they tend to be very fragile,  
especially across versions and platforms. A Web-based presentation may  
prove far easier.

You can *always* link out to a Web page from a PowerPoint slide if you  
just have a few instances where you need Flash/Quicktime and are happy  
with PowerPoint for the rest - this is easy enough, and other than the  
slight loss of immersion when you switch between apps works just fine.

-R
panovrx-2

Re: Pano with Powerpoint

Reply Threaded More More options
Print post
Permalink
In reply to this post by Keith Martin-2
Maybe you can insert a htm with a Flash panorama in it -- as an ActiveX control on Windows
.. or Spi-V maybe

Peter M

--- In [hidden email], Keith Martin <keith@...> wrote:

>
> Sometime around 26/10/09 (at 19:22 +0000) 1drey said:
>
> >Seems that this question is tabooed here - I asked it a month ago
> >and didn't get any responce :)
>
> Not taboo to my knowledge - but perhaps nobody has an answer! That's
> usually what 'no answer' means... ;-)
>
> PowerPoint isn't great for this. You can insert a QuickTime VR
> panorama but it may not work properly across platforms even if
> QuickTime is installed. You can't insert a Flash-based .swf panorama.
> Basically, PowerPoint is a bad, bad choice. Why this software?
>
> k
>


RichardG-2

Re: Pano with Powerpoint

Reply Threaded More More options
Print post
Permalink
In os x, just use the insert mov. comand for your panorama.
check out: http://www.indezine.com/products/powerpoint/ppqtvr.html
Richard

> Maybe you can insert a htm with a Flash panorama in it -- as an ActiveX control on Windows
> .. or Spi-V maybe
>
> Peter M
>
> --- In [hidden email], Keith Martin <keith@> wrote:
> >
> > Sometime around 26/10/09 (at 19:22 +0000) 1drey said:
> >
> > >Seems that this question is tabooed here - I asked it a month ago
> > >and didn't get any responce :)
> >
> > Not taboo to my knowledge - but perhaps nobody has an answer! That's
> > usually what 'no answer' means... ;-)
> >
> > PowerPoint isn't great for this. You can insert a QuickTime VR
> > panorama but it may not work properly across platforms even if
> > QuickTime is installed. You can't insert a Flash-based .swf panorama.
> > Basically, PowerPoint is a bad, bad choice. Why this software?
> >
> > k
> >
>